Rick Rubin & the Weekly Update

Tomorrow’s NYTimes magazine includes “The Music Man,” (free registration may be required) an in-depth look at Rick Rubin’s new role as co-head of Columbia Records.

I take Columbia’s move to bring Rubin on board as good news. If anyone can make something interesting out of the recording industry, it might be him.

Columbia [doesn’t] want Rubin to punch a clock. It wanted him to save the company. And just maybe the record business.

What that means, most of all, is that the company wants him to listen. It is Columbia’s belief that Rubin will hear the answers in the music — that he will find the solution to its ever-increasing woes. The mighty music business is in free fall — it has lost control of radio; retail outlets like Tower Records have shut down; MTV rarely broadcasts music videos; and the once lucrative album market has been overshadowed by downloaded singles, which mainly benefits Apple.

“The music business, as a whole, has lost its faith in content,” David Geffen, the legendary music mogul, told me recently. “Only 10 years ago, companies wanted to make records, presumably good records, and see if they sold. But panic has set in, and now it’s no longer about making music, it’s all about how to sell music. And there’s no clear answer about how to fix that problem. But I still believe that the top priority at any record company has to be coming up with great music. And for that reason, Sony was very smart to hire Rick.”

Are answers really in the music?  There is a wealth of great music being made right now.  We don’t lack good art.  The problem is at the interface between good art and business, and I think Rubin digs that; it may be the old guard at Columbia, and/or perhaps Lynn Hirschberg (who wrote the Times Magazine article) who think the answers are “in the music.”

With so much music flooding the interwebs and everywhere else, there is a business role – i.e. money to be made – for a company that can build a reputation for finding great musicians, making recordings, and delivering their music to listeners in ways that listeners want.  Rubin has impeccable taste for the finding and making.  It’s the delivery that’s both satisfying to listeners and profitable to the artist and company that no one has figured out.

From the article, Rubin seems convinced that a universal subscription model is inevitable.  As a customer, I don’t immediately feel good about that.  That may be because my listening is still mostly tied to plastic discs; I haven’t even joined the iPod iRevolution iYet, which tends to change listening habits considerably.  I have been pretty excited about the subscription-based “Netflix-for-books” services out there, though.  And the fee would have to be less than I currently spend on music.  So logically, it would seem I should be all for it.

Rubin’s co-head of Columbia isn’t convinced of the subscription plan.  But I agree with Rick that it will take a shift of that order and magnitude to transform the recording industry into something positive for both art and commerce.

\\\\

I spent one night at Matt’s for 5*C this week, and we laid down a really rad new jam and started messing with “Silver Yellow Girl” (I want to do a new version from the ground up, sounding similar to the “v2” on myspace but cleaner, starting over with those ideas in mind).  We played last night at the Brick with Aubrey and Distance to Empty (went well) and Joel said he’s stoked to hear what we’ve been cooking up.

I also talked to a couple people about Sally Ride’s upcoming …Boots this week; Katy Lindhart, who will sing a role TBD, Jill Gillespie, who had an excellent casting idea for the character of the Teacher, and Jody Wright, who expressed interest in staging the whole mess (dream come true if it happens).  -h

It Was Garage Rock…

…in Emporia, KS last night as 5*C gave our best to Josie’s, bass-less.

I fired up the Frankentar, my Yamaha “Eterna” Strat knock-off equipped with some gnarly pickups and a Roland GK that drives a bass synth.  The synth sounds pretty plain on its own, but when it’s doubling riffs or the roots of chords, the whole combo starts to kick a little.

Without keys or bass, our neo-80s dance-pop transforms into a mix of Kinks-ish garage rock, Franz Ferdinand-style post-punk, and Joel’s good songs.  It’s fun, it’s a little loose, and it’s a decent change of pace from our usual mode, though I’d never trade them out for more than a night or two at a time.

The new Josie’s building has great vibes; I know Emporia-Matt has to work really hard to put on rock shows, which is a shame now that he finally has a cool space to work with.  There are even two booths right by the door that are perfect for merch.  The man treats his bands well.

With any luck, 5*Matt and I will have a night to work on recording this coming week, and we’ll have a night of practice with Mychael for Friday night’s show at the Brick with Distance to Empty.

What's In a Name, 5*Update, and Joe Boyd

What if Cory and I were going to go on a tour, playing all kinds of songs from the MFR catalog – what would we call ourselves??? A new name, an old name? Comments are open.

\\\\

My studio gear has been successfully moved to Matt’s house for the next phase of Five Star Crush work. We’ll be recording songs, ideas, jams, and whatnot with electronic drums and keys/bass for Joel to work with later. I’m stoked. After two nights of work (and wrestling with g*****n Windows XP), we have a basic understanding of MIDI; one more evening of set-up, and we should be off and rolling.

Matt is going to borrow a bass for me to use. I’m starting to think that maybe if I switch back and forth between bass and keyboard (within single songs) that 5*C could work as a 3-piece. Especially if Matt gets some samples/atmosphere rocking on his drum pads. Hasn’t been tried yet, though, we’ll see.

\\\\

In June, Pitchfork did a great interview with Joe Boyd. Joe’s recently written a memoir; he knew everybody in the 60’s, and Pfork says his book is worth the read whether you know/care about that music or not.

The whole conversation is a cool read, talking about the Newport Folk Festival, the differences between European and American folk audiences, and other interesting big-picture observations of pop music since the 1950’s. The best is at the end:

Pitchfork: What part of that period [the 1960’s -howie] is such a magnet even 40 years later?

Boyd: I do think there’s a little bit of a problem for people making music today in the sense that there aren’t many new forms. Obviously hip-hop is a new form that’s been invented since the 60s and that’s had a lot of energy and has cleared a space for itself in a way. But the guitar-bass-drum rock band and the singer-songwriter with a guitar– those forms are getting a little tired. And it’s hard for people to come up with something really original, I think. Which is why– and I haven’t really listened to them that much– you get the feeling that groups like the Arcade Fire, who are playing around with rhythmic feels and different instrumentations, have a better chance of coming up with something fresh. You can walk down 6th Street at South by Southwest in Austin and hear that same snare-drum backbeat and that same rhythm-guitar pattern coming out of one bar after another. You’re not feeling optimistic that you’re going to walk into one of those bars and hear something that you’ve never heard before. Most of the ground has been covered.

Pitchfork: Do you think there’s anything else on the horizon? Or do you think it will keep advancing in revivals?

Boyd: Well, you have to believe that there’s something new around the corner somewhere. But it is difficult because I think what we had in the sixties, however illusional or delusional it was, we were optimistic. And when you’re optimistic, you can create more stuff that’s new. You feel like you’re looking forward into a great, big, open, warm, sunny space, and you can go in there with positive feelings of being able to do something new. Today, people are looking backwards. It’s like, “Don’t tear down that old building,” because you feel like if you build something new on that site, it’s going to be worse than what was there. Same thing about a lot of things…clothing or whatever. These quotes from the past dominate what’s new, because people don’t feel confident in being able to take a blank piece of paper and being able to draw something freehand and coming up with something that’s better than before. Whereas we did! When you have that confidence, it’s very different. It creates a very different atmosphere. It opens up things that don’t get opened up otherwise.

The dearth of new musical forms – and new art forms in general – concerns me.  I had a conversation with Jill the other night about how we seem to be pushing up against the limits of what can be expressed in the art forms we know… and how human augmentation might open up new artistic possibilities.

Maybe a new form will emerge from a pocket of people somewhere outside of the West… but new forms develop in isolation, and there are few places left that Western culture hasn’t reached.  Seems like mostly what we have are kids making hip-hop in their native tongues, or older kids blending their local folk musics with Western pop forms.  There’s interesting stuff in those areas, but not entirely new forms.  Not another rock ‘n roll; not another punk; not another hip-hop.

When I was a kid I wanted to discover a new color.  Now I’d like to create a new musical form.  I won’t; forms emerge spontaneously, from communities – a critical mass of people and artists building on their traditions and transforming them to deal with new circumstances, often situations of oppression, poverty, and injustice.  From the Batcave in Raytown, Missouri, middle-class U.S.A… it’s not happening.

There’s still decent music to be made.  People have an insatiable appetite for music, which is nice for musicians.  I’m happy to feed that hunger, always seeking the higher harmonic that satisfies me and satisfies my audience at once (AKA, not being just a cover band; though I respect that, it doesn’t satisfy me).

I can say a lot for making music within established forms, and doing it well.  There is a clarity of purpose in that.  It’s not easy; you have to be better than what’s come before, to distill the form into a more concentrated thing, plus add a twist (See: Five Star Crush).

Boyd talks about the difference confidence makes.  I see the lack of confidence in every genre-band I hear; artists who only create their art with a basic level of competence towards the conventions of a single form.  It’s so competent I find it aesthetically offensive (Hello, Nickelback!  Ack.  Easy target).

There are wonderful musicians making great music today, maybe more than ever before.  But do we have the confidence – dare I say faith? – that we can say something new?  Honestly, I doubt the West does.  In the US, it’s an open question whether we have the confidence to maintain our democracy.  Confidence in art, confidence in our social contract; which informs the other?  My songs are statements of faith in art, and I hope that by them confidence may bleed over into other worthwhile causes.  -h

The Sad, Surprising Relevance of "It's A Trap"

I wrote most of Sally Ride’s second record, It’s A Trap, in June and July last summer during the run-up to the 2006 mid-term elections.  The war had been steadily going from bad (aka, strategically and tactically unsound, illegal, and sold on untrue premeses) to worse.  The chances that We the People might achieve electoral victories seemed slight.  With our national media, and therefore our national conversation, obsessed with trivia it felt like a trap.

To my surprise*, the Democrats won big by running against Bush’s war and his complete trashing of our Constitution, and we seemed headed for change.

Recording and mixing the record took longer than I had hoped, and so a bunch of the songs with more specifically political elements (“Lookers,” “Baby Bells,” “Addington,” “We the People”) written in a pre-election context seemed to have lost their bite when the album finally came out December 20.  There wasn’t anything we could have done differently.  But I was bummed.  I’d wanted to have It’s A Trap out as part of the election process.

How sad, then, that political developments this past week rendered these year-old issues freshly relevant.

“Lookers” – Congress has just passed sweeping new authorization of Bush’s domestic spying/eavesdropping program, giving the President legal cover to go even further than he has gone, illegally, for the past several years.

“David S. Addington and Your Democracy” – As chief legal architect of Bush’s feudalist power-grab known as the theory of the “unitary executive,” Congress has not sufficiently pushed back on the executive branch’s unconstitutional actions.  You’d think the Dems could stand up to a President with 66% disapproval ratings; you’d think wrong.

“We the People” – As a more general song about us masses versus the kleptocrats who’d just luuuv to be new feudal lords, “We the People” has a constant back-burner level of relevance in any free society.  I had expected the Dem Congress to reduce the front-burner urgency of our need to stand together against the would-be-lords, but it has not, and the call is still loud and clear for us to get up en masse and save our democracy.

“goddamn” – A song written at this time, in this style, that will be a part of SR’s new You Have To Wear the Boots, with the lines:

“We heard about Ohio in Rolling Stone; Blackwell’s party stole their state for George.

Death by 1000 cuts and no one cares, the streets ‘re empty.”

New reports of the illegal destruction of ballots in 2/3 of Ohio precincts, an inconceivable coincidence, can only lead us to believe that there was indeed something to hide; that Ohio was stolen, giving Bush his second term.  I can’t even parse or internalize the implications of this statement, which my head believes to be true even if my heart can’t figure out how to act like it.
We take open, lawful society for granted.  We forget that it’s not the ‘natural’ state of things; that 99% of humans who ever lived, lived under feudalism with one mask or another.  Democracy requires constant education, participation, maintenance, and vigilance.  Americans, we’ve been lazy.  Our forefathers and mothers would be ashamed.  We still have access to the tools to take our government back; certifiably fair elections and independent media.  We can’t afford not to use them, with the impending global warming crisis breathing down our necks.

I’m going to try a couple things, maybe tonight, but look forward to announcements on an improved and re-mastered It’s A Trap soon.  I’m happy it still has a role to play in our political conversation (it has other things to say about love), but distraught at the state of things in which I feel moved to speak.  -h
*Which says something about the Dems utter inability to capitalize on Bush’s nearly endless political weaknesses, Americans’ broad support for classically liberal (Adam Smith) policies, or the ready-to-fracture Republican coalition of neoconservatives, dogmatic libertarians, Christian dominionists, and decent conservatives who don’t realize their party has been hijacked.  Most days I wonder if they even want to win elections.  They’re certainly not serious about it.

Music Rags

After years spent as a loyal SPIN reader, you, ma’am, have been replaced.

My free trial issue of Paste has usurped my allegiance.  Andy Whitman’s blog was my introduction, followed by Ctrl+V.

Issue #33 came in last week’s mail.  The first ten or so tracks of the CD have been mildly interesting.  Petur Ben and Fields are both groovy, but God knows what Cake’s instrumental b-side “Conroy” is doing on it.

The mag itself sealed the deal; overflowing with intelligent, earnest writing about good music from the top 40 to Carolina Chocolate Drops and everything in-between.  Limited ads, mostly for records I’d probably like.  Makes SPIN look like the magazine equivalent of VH1’s “Best Week Ever,” full of entirely predictable snarking and reveling in empty pleasures.  SPIN’s review section sucks too now; what good is it to write a thousand fifty-word reviews and give every record three out of five stars?

No good, that’s what.

Today I love Paste.  It is a good magazine+CD about good music.  Love, -howie

HRC, Hot Items at the Archive, and Full-On Sally Ride

Thanks to everyone who has voted for 5*C to open the Buzz’s Beach Ball 3 – if you haven’t yet, do!

Joel, Matt, and I are in the studio again this week, working on a new version of “Aasta.” We’re at HRC in KCK for the first time. They’re still building and ironing out kinks, which is partly why we’re there (to give their gear a workout), and it is clearly going to be a classy facility when it’s complete.

Our most-downloaded-items page at archive.org is getting interesting. The Archive changed the way they calculate “downloads” a couple months ago to include hits on files linked from remote servers (such as those of mrfuriousrecords.com). That means that only since then have your downloads actually counted towards our total. I’m pretty excited about the albums over 1,000 downloads, and I’m even more pumped on the steady growth of our whole catalog.

I’m considering re-mastering Sally Ride’s It’s A Trap, because the trick that Duane showed me while mastering 5*C’s “Silver Yellow Girl v2” the other week would really help that record out a lot. Despite my best efforts at the time, it also seems overfull in the low-mids (mostly due to all the organ buried in there) and I wouldn’t mind having another go at reining those in.

In terms of my post-howie&scott output I’ve loosely called Sally Ride my “rock” music and Tape/echoes my “pop,” with the former emphasizing guitar riffs and… rocking… while the latter was about melodies and catchiness in any form. This distinction is probably silly and definitely confusing for nearly everyone. Given that SR is working on our third major project, and Tape/echoes has only two EPs and an acoustic thing to its name, I thought the other day that it might be a good idea to just go with “Sally Ride” for every-damn-thing. It has a ring to it, it’s feminist, I think it’s kind of punk and subversive, and it’s where I’ve done/am doing what’s clearly superior work (in the relative sense).

I invite your comments.

It does feel slightly weird to imagine Ventura by Sally Ride… but I think I can make the mental switch, no one else will notice, and everything will become beautiful.

I’ve been listening to hip-hop, which is my comfort music: Common, A Tribe Called Quest, Combine.

Pfork blog

This last weekend, Matt Wisecarver and I were fortunate enough to visit Chicago for the Pitckfork Music Fest. It was also our first time visiting Chicago, so we got a lot of awesome stuff under our belts.
Before I get to the bands/festival, here are some quick highlights:
  • Ate pizza for pretty much every meal.
  • Drank roughly 4 troughs of Goose Island Beer, a brew out of Chicago but available in the Midwest.
  • Stayed with my old friend Katie, who studies eyeballs but is very nice regardless. She was an excellent host.
  • Visited Reckless Records, Intelligensia Coffee, and Nookie’s Diner.
  • Saw two crazy boys jumping speed-bumps on a yellow moped, holding each other and giggling.
  • Experienced Wrigleyville game-day madness (didn’t go to the game, though).
  • Paid $10.95 for a pack of cloves.
  • Visited a mega-bar called The Sheffield, and met crazy weirdos.
  • Visited a comfy, worn-in dive bar called Nisei Lounge and did a Jager-Bomb with the bartender.
  • Hung out with Doane pals Julia Worth and Brandon Anderson.
  • Was spied on by window-men.
  • Visited the lake, played the “t-shirt” game.
Now, a rundown of my Pitchfork Music Fest experience:
First of all, it was a very well-run event. There were no fights, riots, altercations, or anything. Everyone there seemed to be pretty cool, although some d-bags were throwing cardboard show-flyers into the air, which is cool if you’re 10, but I digress. The water was cheap (1 dollar), the food and the beer was reasonably priced (4 dollars for a microbrew and about 5 dollars for a meal), and they had various activities like basketball and beanbags to keep people busy, plus mist-spraying cool-down tents. And now for some comments on the bands.
Day ONE:
Grizzly Bear- Seemed like they’d be awesome to listen to while relaxing or on a road trip or something, but didn’t own the audience like a band should at a huge outdoor festival. They were ambient and had weird arrangements, and I guess I just wanted to be smacked in the face with music. I think the goal for any festival playing band is blow the audience’s minds. But they sounded pretty cool.
Battles- I had high expectations for this instrumentalish experimental dance-rock band, but again, I was kind of let down. I mean, their stuff sounded pretty cool, and I’m sure I would have loved it if I saw it in a small club, but during some of their set, they just sounded so SMALL. And kind of unorganized. They were at their best when the drummer was going nuts.
Iron and Wine- I had hardly heard any of their stuff, but they had plenty of people onstage doing stuff to really round out the sound, and they were excellent, beautiful, and totally captivating, besides some crackling on the vocals during part of the set. Folk music rules. I heard some Calypso in there, too.
Mastodon- Holy Shit. METAL! They owned. They were awesome/aggressive/terrifying. They played my favorites. There was even a mosh-pit (!!![???]). They put on a SHOW, and had a gigantic “Blood Mountain” banner behind them. Yikes! I wish I could pull off that kind of facial hair.
Clipse- The highlight of Day 1. The hip-hop duo just came on and made the crowd GET DOWN! Their skills were awesome, the beats were sick, and they were very gracious, especially when expressing their gratitude towards the Pitchfork community for giving them so much love and support. Hip-hop shows are hard to top, and these dudes just came out and went NUTS!
Cat Power- I thought I might be more pumped on this motherfolker, but for whatever reason, I was a lot less interested than I thought I’d be. Probably because I was buzzed, tired, and dehydrated.
We didn’t stay for Yoko Ono, although I guess she brought out Thurston Moore from Sonic Youth. I just don’t know ANY of her songs. Plus, we wanted to beat the crowd on the train. She’s 74!!!!!!! DANG!
My second day of Pitchfork was just as cool as the first. I think I heard some more cool bands, anyway.
Menomena- I caught about 3 of their songs, and they were awesome, but I can’t remember what exactly they sounded like. Visit their myspace!
Junior Boys- Cool awesome dance music with rock vocals. Totally fun to listen to. The program likened them to Justin Timberlake beats, and I wouldn’t say that, but they ruled either way.
Jamie Lidell- this was one of the highlights of the festival. Lidell, from the UK somewhere, is this guy who writes and records the backing tracks for his music. Then, when he plays live, he’s by himself, and he sings along, and these songs are SOUL SONGS. And he totally captivates the crowd. Like Sam Cooke or some shit. Other times, he’ll just play some grooves on his turntables, but it’s all very fun to listen to. He had a terrific voice, and he looked like a “homeless bloke” (his words). He was wearding this weird shitty leopard pring shirt and he had all sorts of paper or something streaming from his head.
Stephen Malkmus (from Pavement and The Jicks)- It was mostly just Stephen, although he was periodically accompanied by a drummer friend during the set. He played some gnarly classics including “Spit On A Stranger” from Terror Twilight. Which was beautiful. The only bummer is that, because he was so quiet compared to the rest of the bands, you could REALLY heard Of Montreal sound-checking at the other stage I mean, it was necessary, but I couldn’t help feel that Of Montreal were being rude. But…
Of Montreal- ROCKED! I just started listening to these guys a few months ago, and they are awesome fun psychadelic pop music from Athens, GA (and yeah, they are connected to Elephant 6/Neutral Milk Hotel/Elf Power/etc.). They are weird and profound and sexy, and put on one of the WEIRDEST live shows I’ve ever seen. Lobter-handed debutantes (sp?), golden-jumpsuited women painting themselves, dudes in fencing outfits, an alien pretending to sing, and the lead singer, Kevin Barnes (who swears he’s straight) looking pretty in red eye shadow, a black corset, a black biker hat, black leather panties with a zipper in the front, and a black garter belt. Yuck! And, BOING!
New Pornographers- Sounded cool but I was too busy drinking and chatting to really pay a ton of attention. I was tired.
De La Soul- Okay, so they sounded the best out of every single band there the whole weekend. They were awesome, energetic, funny, and they sounded HUGE AND AWESOME. Unfortunately, we were exhausted again, and we left during their set. It was a necessary evil, as we also had to beat the MASSIVE CROWD to the train station. I mean, it would have been nasty. I hope I get to see them again when I’m not totally burned out.
Love,
Cory Alan

Exciting

Busy week/end/w*eek/end/week.  I’m about where the star is tonight.

The exciting thing is that tomorrow night, Joel and I are going to the studio to re-do the keys and remix 5*C’s “Silver Yellow Girl” for the 96.5 the Buzz contest we’re in.  Roman Numerals and Republic Tigers are in the contest as well, so it’s intense competition and we’re pretty honored to be considered in those ranks.

I heard a Paul McCartney song from Chaos and Creation in the Backyard today that gave me a good idea of the type of recording style and sound I want for Ventura.  It’s nice to have a more concrete idea of what that could feel like.

See you –

-h

Forgot to title the post

I spent three hours making some space on my HD and installing Firefox (late the the party, I know) in order to participate in today’s LiveEarth concerts, and the video is slowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww.

But I also installed one of those awesome spiral-efficient lightbulbs, and know I need to find a reliable org than I can pay to offset my 16 tons of atmospheric carbon-generation for 2007.

\\\\

I think I’ll call my vocal/electric base tracks for …Boots complete. There are wrinkles in two songs I wish I could iron out, but the emotion is there, and that’s the point of recording the project live.

This thing unfolds at a slightly different speed, kids, so just know. In a way, some of the marks of my howie&scott / signs material – expressive guitar figures iterating for a couple minutes at a time, permutating melodies, long phrases that force simple song structures past the 4 1/2-minute mark – have resurfaced, which is interesting. I only began to notice that as I started listening back to the recordings.

After Cory’s base tracks are down I’m moving all the gear to 5*Matt’s house, where we intend to begin a massive demo-ing project incorporating the electronic drum kit and some edgier guitar sounds. I’m afraid of diminishing our warm, American, organic side too much but there is also some promise in this direction, for Joel especially. I’m excited because nothing is set in stone; we just need to explore this territory for ourselves.

Listening to: Soundgarden Louder Than Love, Joe Henry Fuse, Koufax Social Life, and System of a Down Toxicity.